Home Viewpoints

TOPICS
401(k)
Bond Fund
Bonds
COVID-19
Commodity Investments
Corporate Bonds
Cybersecurity
Equity Fund
Equity Investing
Europe
Events
Exchange-Traded Funds
Federal Reserve
Financial Markets
Financial Stability
Fixed Income
Fund Governance
Fund Regulation
GMM
Global
Government Affairs
ICI Global
IDC
IRA
Index Fund
Interest Rate
International
Investment Education
Investor Research
Money Market Funds
Mutual Fund
Operations and Technology
Policy Research
Proxy Voting
Retirement Policy
Retirement Research
Savings
Shareholder
Target Date Funds
Taxes
Trading
Treasury
ARCHIVE
Growing Better with Age: The 401(k) Turns Forty
By Miriam Bridges and Christina Kilroy
November 30, 2018
This month marks the fortieth birthday of the most prevalent retirement plan available to workers today: the 401(k). It’s a milestone, to be sure, but there are no mid-life doldrums here—401(k) plans continue to grow, and currently hold $5.3 trillion in assets on behalf of more than 55 million active participants and millions of former employees and retirees.
The 401(k) plan’s namesake—perhaps the most recognizable subsection of the US tax code, Section 401, subsection (k)—lets workers contribute a portion of their pay into a tax-advantaged investment account. Participants defer taxes on their contributions until those funds are taken out of the account in retirement.
Although a small number of cash or deferred arrangements (CODAs) had existed since the 1950s, Congress created the modern 401(k) when it passed the Revenue Act of 1978 on November 6, 1978. After the IRS issued proposed regulations three years later, employers began to adopt the plans in earnest. Large employers typically offered 401(k) plans as a supplement to their existing defined benefit (DB) plans—commonly known as traditional pensions—rather than as a stand-alone retirement option. Over time, firms that did not already have a retirement plan, particularly start-up businesses, adopted 401(k) plans as their primary retirement plan and as funding rules for traditional pensions tightened, many employers made 401(k)s their primary plans.
The 401(k) fits the needs of American companies and workers as our workforce has changed. And today’s private-sector retirement system—including both DB and defined contribution (DC) plans such as the 401(k)—is providing more benefits to more people than ever before. Retirees today receive more income, on average, than their counterparts in the 1970s who only had access to DB plans. ICI research shows that the share of retirees with private-sector retirement income has nearly doubled since 1975. More importantly, the median amount received by retirees has increased by more than 50 percent—and this is true across income groups.
Forty and Favored
The 401(k) is an increasingly important part of a retirement system that has helped retirees maintain or increase their spendable income—a fact that is not lost on American workers. In an ICI study on Americans’ views of DC plans, the results were clear: more than three-quarters of households—whether they owned these accounts or not—were confident in the ability of DC plans to help people meet their retirement goals. At 84 percent, confidence was even higher among those who owned DC accounts or individual retirement accounts (IRAs).
DC plan account owners also expressed appreciation of the basic features of this form of retirement saving, including the opportunities for individual choice in investing, the tax treatment of the savings, personal control of the retirement assets, and the ability to save and invest automatically, paycheck by paycheck.
Growing Better with Age
401(k)s have evolved to become an effective building block in providing retirement security to millions of working Americans. The 401(k) can be stronger still—working together, policymakers, employers, and the financial industry can further strengthen the 401(k). Improvements, such as automatic enrollment, automatic increases in contributions, and target date funds have made saving in 401(k) plans easier for workers. Easing administrative complexities would make it easier for small employers to offer plans, building on the 40-year record of growth and innovation of our current retirement system and fostering its future success.
The 401(k) is set to conquer its forties and continue providing Americans with incentives to save, invest, and think long-term.
401(k) Resources
If you’re one of the many millions of American workers who is focused on saving in a 401(k) plan, ICI has resources to help you learn more:
- FactsOnRetirement.org, which offers facts to counter myths about the US retirement system, as well as tips for savers.
- FAQs on the basics of 401(k) plans, which offer guidance on what exactly a 401(k) plan is and how it works, including information about employer matches, catch-up contributions, vesting, loans, withdrawals, and required minimum distributions.
- FAQs on ICI’s 401(k) plan research, which offer information about the 401(k) plan market and participant activity.
- Ten Important Facts About 401(k) Plans, which offer a collection of interesting facts pulled from ICI’s research papers and data collections.
See ICI’s 401(k) Resource Center, where we have all of the above resources and more, including videos, news releases, and policy statements. Also, follow us on social media—including Facebook, Twitter, and LinkedIn—to receive information about top news stories on the industry, notices of ICI releases, and stories on 401(k)s and retirement.
Miriam Bridges is ICI’s editorial director and Tina Kilroy is vice president of the ICI Education Foundation.
Permalink: https://www.ici.org/viewpoints/view_18_401k_bday
TOPICS: 401(k)Investor ResearchPolicy ResearchRetirement PolicyRetirement ResearchSavingsShareholderTarget Date Funds
Common Ownership: Ignoring the Age-Old Conflict Between Owners and Managers
By Mike McNamee
November 30, 2018
In his first public remarks as a member of the Federal Trade Commission, Commissioner Noah Joshua Phillips tackled what he called “the common ownership story”—and concluded that “this ‘economic blockbuster’ seems a little light on plot.” And like many other experts, Commissioner Phillips sees problems with both the empirical evidence and the theoretical basis for the claim of anticompetitive harm....
TOPICS: Financial MarketsFund RegulationPolicy ResearchShareholder
Common Ownership: Faulty Assumptions on Investors’ ‘Economic Interests’
By Mike McNamee
November 29, 2018
In a new paper, scholars Thomas A. Lambert and Michael E. Sykuta find that proponents of the common ownership hypothesis don’t understand—or even attempt to consider—the actual economic interests and incentives of asset managers and their fund clients....
TOPICS: Financial MarketsFund RegulationPolicy ResearchShareholder
Funds and Proxy Voting: Funds Vote Thoughtfully and Independently
By Morris Mitler, Sean Collins, and Dorothy Donohue
November 7, 2018
During the 2017 proxy voting season, registered investment companies—including mutual funds, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), and closed-end funds—cast more than 7.6 million votes for proxy proposals submitted by either management or shareholders of corporations held in the funds’ portfolios. Some of those proposals were straightforward; others were more controversial. But in every case, a fund adviser had a duty to evaluate the proposal and act in the best interest of the fund and its shareholders.
TOPICS: Mutual FundProxy VotingShareholder
Funds and Proxy Voting: Who Submits Shareholder Proposals?
By Morris Mitler, Sean Collins, and Dorothy Donohue
November 6, 2018
Any registered fund that holds companies’ stocks in its portfolio has a duty to consider proxy proposals offered by those companies—and to act in the best interests of the fund and its shareholders. These funds also have a regulatory obligation to report those votes.
As the only investors required to disclose their votes publicly, funds draw an outsized share of the attention focused on proxy issues and voting outcomes. And critics frequently focus on whether they agree or disagree with funds’ votes—without regard to funds’ obligation to vote in the interests of fund shareholders....
TOPICS: Mutual FundProxy VotingShareholder
Funds and Proxy Voting: The Mix of Proposals Matters
By Morris Mitler, Sean Collins, and Dorothy Donohue
November 5, 2018
Proxy voting is in the news and on the minds of policymakers, corporate executives, and investors. The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) will focus on a number of issues related to proxy advisory firms, shareholder proposals, and technology and innovation to make the proxy process more efficient at a staff roundtable on November 15. Major corporate issuers—organized as the “Main Street Investors Coalition”—are agitating against the voting practices of institutional investors, including registered funds....
Fund Shareholders Have to Receive Reports. They Don’t Have to Pay So Much for Them
By Paul Schott Stevens
November 1, 2018
ICI has filed a comment letter calling on the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to overhaul the framework for fees that funds are required to pay to vendors when intermediaries such as broker-dealers hire those vendors to distribute legally required reports and disclosures to shareholders. The issue may sound dry and technical—but if the SEC follows through on our recommendations, shareholders will save real money.
TOPICS: Mutual FundShareholder
Copyright © 2021 by the Investment Company Institute