To comply with changing international privacy requirements, ICI informs its visitors that we use cookies on our web site. ICI only uses cookies to allow subscribers and members to more easily use our site and to record site utilization. No personal or private information is gathered or stored. More details, including how to disable cookies, can be found on our privacy and cookie policy page. If you disable cookies, you will see this message on future visits to our site. Please click the enable button to consent to accepting cookies.
  • ICI Global
  • Independent Director's Council
Sign In  |  Forgot Password?
Advanced | Tips
  • Home
  • Policy Priorities
    • Fund Regulation
    • Retirement Security
    • Trading & Markets
    • Fund Governance
    • Taxes
    • ICI Comment Letters
  • Research & Statistics
    • Industry Research
    • Investor Research
    • Retirement Research
    • Statistics
  • Government Affairs
    • Financial Services
    • Retirement Security
    • Tax
    • Testimony
  • Industry Operations
    • Fund Accounting, Financial Reporting, and Valuation
    • Fund Distribution, Fund Clearance, and Settlement
    • Operations, Transfer Agent Servicing, and Recordkeeping
    • Portfolio Security Operations
    • Resource Centers
    • Technology, Business Continuity, and Information Security
  • News & Media
    • Media Contacts
    • News Releases
    • Blog: ICI Viewpoints
    • Speeches & Commentaries
    • Opinions & Responses
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
  • Publications & Resources
    • Resource Centers
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Fact Books
    • Research Publications
    • White Papers
    • Annual Reports
  • Events
    • ICI Events
    • ICI Global Events
    • IDC Events
    • Past Event Highlights
    • Sponsorship Opportunities
    • Event Contacts
  • About ICI
    • Mission & History
    • Board & Leadership
    • Membership
    • Annual Reports
    • ICI Education Foundation
    • Business Continuity
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
  • Fund Regulation
    • Advertising
    • Broker-Dealer & Principal Underwriter Issues
    • CFTC Rule 4.5
    • Compliance
    • Derivatives
    • Disclosure
    • Electronic Delivery
    • Enforcement Actions
    • Fees
    • Financial Stability
    • Fixed-Income Securities
    • Investment Advisers
    • International
    • Municipal Securities
    • Privacy
    • Products
    • Risk Management
    • State Issues
    • Valuation
  • Retirement Security
    • Support of a Defined Contribution System
    • Regulatory Activities
    • Legislation
    • International
    • Plan Type
    • State Issues
    • Current Topics
      • Target Date Funds
      • Money Market Funds
      • Fiduciary Definition
      • E-Delivery
      • Lifetime Income
      • Fee Disclosure
  • Trading & Markets
    • Domestic
    • Global
  • Fund Governance
    • Directors & Fund Governance
    • Corporate Governance
  • Taxes
    • FATCA
    • Foreign Tax Issues
    • Information Reporting
    • Legislation
    • State Tax Issues
    • U.S. Taxation of Mutual Funds & Shareholders
    • 529 Plans
  • ICI Comment Letters

Home Policy Priorities Taxes U.S. Taxation of Mutual Funds & Shareholders

Print this page

Financial Transaction Tax Costs

By Paul Schott Stevens

(As published in InvestmentNews, November 11, 2019)

Dear editor,

Your story “Elizabeth Warren Healthcare Plan Sparks Outcry over 401(k) Tax Hike” accurately exposes a financial transaction tax (FTT) as a burden on retirement and everyday savers. The article, however, only scratches the surface on the ways this tax would harm savers.

Yes, retirement savers would pay an FTT each time they make a 401(k) contribution, rebalance their accounts, or roll money from one 401(k) plan to another. But savers could also pay the price of an FTT at other times, compounding its harm. Investors in a long-term mutual fund would incur an FTT at least four times:

  • First: when investors buy shares of a mutual fund. If imposed on these transactions in 2018, a 10-basis-point FTT would have cost long-term mutual fund investors $4.4 billion. 
  • Second: when investors sell mutual fund shares. The cost: $4.5 billion.
  • Third: when the mutual fund an investor owns buys stocks and bonds, including rebalancing the fund to track an index. The tax on those necessary trades would cost $9.5 billion. 
  • Fourth: when mutual funds sell stocks and bonds, again, including rebalancing a portfolio. The tax on these transactions: $9 billion.

That is an aggregate annual cost of $27.4 billion.

Worse yet, these are just the direct costs to mutual fund investors. An FTT would also raise the cost of executing a trade, and the increase in trading costs could be many times the direct cost. 

In the end, Main Street investors are going to face heavy costs from any FTT. It’s not worth it.

Paul Schott Stevens is president and CEO of the Investment Company Institute.


top
  • About ICI
  • About IDC
  • About ICI Global
  • Privacy and Cookie Policy
  • Apply for User Account
  • Business Continuity
  • Contact ICI

Copyright © 2021 by the Investment Company Institute